Jump to content


What and Who is English

Recommended Posts

It's obviously going to be very difficult to define what being ' English ' is, just as it would be difficult to absolutely define what any individual's ethnicity or nation was. However, although we wouldn't describe a man who steals things now and then as a ' confirmed thief ' i. e. he steals all the time, in the same way we should not shrink from defining or trying to define what being English is.

 

It's much easier to give examples. For example, if anyone checks on Sheffield Forum in the ' History & Ex-Pats ' section they can easily see what, for example, a ' community ' is. They are a group of people with a lot in common and who have had a lot in common for at least 2 or 3 or more generations. They speak the same language, generally have the same cultural values and have considerable ' folk ' memories. They tend to inter-marry, live and work near each other [ or did in the recent past ! ] and to a great extent trust each other as a result.

 

Whether it's a village, town, city or country, newcomers are often or always regarded with a certain amount of suspicioun because for obvious reasons they CANNOT share the above values. Ask anyone, born in an English town, what it's like to move into a well-established English village !

 

You can go round in circles for evermore trying to describe ' Englishness '. It's like trying to find the ultimate definition of ' honesty ' or ' truth ' i.e. impossible. however, a lot of us born in England know what we mean, just as a lot of people born in, say, France, would know what being ' French ' is.

 

good post Far East, it's almost as if they 'guard' their Englishness:)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I'm English & love that ENGLAND is multi-cultural :)

 

Yep agree. and its not going to change so people that dont like it will only moan about it on the forum.. Waste of time if you ask me :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
They were completely German by blood actually, but hey!... :hihi:

 

StarSparkle

 

The last English King of England died of an arrow in his eye in 1066 ;)

 

Since then they've been francophone Norwegians, or Welsh, Scots, Dutch Spaniards. Germans - as motley a crew as you could wish for.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
............and so on

 

I'm English. White as the driven snow and born in Allah's own Yorkshire to two White English parents.

 

Until you look closer and find I'm a Muslim convert. Does that make me less English?

I left the country. How about that?

Turns out that my family has a Jewish branch and that out branch were Jewish until the early 1900s. Does that naff things up yet?

 

So if I kept the cake hole shut I could join the BNP or if they find me they could beat me up for being a **** lover. :D

 

Isn't racism foolish? :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mod note: Please keep the chat for the chatroom/pms, and no more innuendo please, remember this is a family forum?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I would define someone as English if they were descended from one of the West European "tribes" that settled in England up to, and including the Norman Invasion in 1066.

 

These "tribes" are defined by Stephen Oppenheimer in his authoritative book "The Origins of the British". They would include Celts, Angles, Saxons, Jutes, Danes, Norse and Normans - a simple DNA test would reveal our ancestral origins.

 

Under your definition Nodens anyone who isn't white can't be English - how bizarre, what's all that about then?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh wouldn't the world be a wonderful place if everyone took people on face value, regardless of race, colour or creed ? but thats never going to happen as like and like are allways going to have a different opinion on life religion and social morals, hence; Get on with your life whatever country you are from, you are only here for the best part of a century and thats not a long time is it ?? Oh and stop spouting better than thou comments and religious dogma as no one is qualified to say we are the best or the one true religion or race.. we are all made of the same bag of watter and bones, its the brain that we were blessed with that causes all the controversy, nothing else :thumbsup: Turn yer brain off and look around you, look past the religious/racial issues and the world suddenly becomes a beautiful place :thumbsup:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A good friend was born and brought up in Sheffield and has lived here all her life, with several generations of her mother's family being born and brought up here too. However, her father was from a different continent. Most of her culture comes from her family, friends and life here in Sheffield yet the first thing some people think about and judge her by is her skin colour. Some would even deny she can be English, based solely on pigment... :shakes:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
A good friend was born and brought up in Sheffield and has lived here all her life, with several generations of her mother's family being born and brought up here too. However, her father was from a different continent. Most of her culture comes from her family, friends and life here in Sheffield yet the first thing some people think about and judge her by is her skin colour. Some would even deny she can be English, based solely on pigment... :shakes:

 

Indeed, Ms MacBeth. It looks as if she mightn't qualify under Nodens criteria of Englishness. I wonder if he'd clarify - perhaps a little bit of non - European blood is Ok?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Indeed, Ms MacBeth. It looks as if she mightn't qualify under Nodens criteria of Englishness. I wonder if he'd clarify - perhaps a little bit of non - European blood is Ok?

 

To be fair, and please correct me if i'm wrong, he didn't say 'purely' of Celtic, Angles, Saxons, Jutes, Danes, Norse and Normans stock, he just said descended from, so you could be as black or brown or pink with little blue stars but as long as you've got some blood from these tribes you'd still be English, even if you didn't speak the language, had no idea what a cup of tea was and couldn't find England on a map.

 

In short, it's a crap definition of Englishness. As many many people from other countries qualify as more English as a second generation immigrant who fully embraces his community.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is no state (ie passport-issuing entity) called England. Therefore, nobody can claim to be English purely on a citizenship basis.

 

That leaves an ethnic/racial criterion. The English are, in law, a national origin racial group. Consequently, only persons of long standing and very well assimilated identity could claim to be English on this basis.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
There is no state (ie passport-issuing entity) called England. Therefore, nobody can claim to be English purely on a citizenship basis.

 

That leaves an ethnic/racial criterion. The English are, in law, a national origin racial group. Consequently, only persons of long standing and very well assimilated identity could claim to be English on this basis.

 

That definition you gave earlier didn't sound like a race to me.

 

You said that anyone who feels english and is accepted by other english to be english is english.

 

I'm english without a doubt and i accept people like tab1 as english so by you're nice 'legal' definition he and lots of other immigrants are. Thanks for clearing that up:thumbsup:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.