Which was the best pub that closed in Sheffield and why?

[choogling 14]

The Cossack and the one where West 1 is now, was it The Hornblower ?

 

Is that a gay pub:hihi:

[anarchist 10]

Easy.

The best pub in Sheffield that closed was The Old Toad/Good Doctor. It was probably the first real ale free house in Sheffield and was closed when they widened St Phillips Road.

[jake 10]

Is that a gay pub:hihi:

 

The Cossack was - despite its name The Hornblower was not - but had a nautical theme and somewhat bizarrely was done up like a ship.. it was a good pub though.. I spent many a weekend night in there

[Fantasia X 10]

Barley Corn on Cambridge St was good back in the 70's,,,

[Jim Hardie 525]

The Hole in The Wall on the Wicker.

 

Savile Street.

[phantom309 10]

Easy.

The best pub in Sheffield that closed was The Old Toad/Good Doctor. It was probably the first real ale free house in Sheffield and was closed when they widened St Phillips Road.

 

It was on Hoyle Street now Netherthorpe Road and was previously " The Talbot " before it was tarted up. St. Phillips Road was around 100 yards further from town.

[greeni 10]

I wish I had gone to the Old Toad, just missed it in the 80s. The road it was on is still called Hoyle Street by the way.

 

What was that real ale pub on the top of Spital Hill in the 90s called? - it had Bar Billiards, and the guy who had it always had classical music playing....

[0114owl1867 10]

and the 'barrow boys'

[Yog Sothoth 10]

Oh and the Matilda Tavern. I still don't understand why someone doesn't buy this and reopen it - a stone's throw from the Rutland Arms, surrounded by student flats, overlooking the river - it'd do the business if it joined the real ale circuit!

[anarchist 10]

I wish I had gone to the Old Toad, just missed it in the 80s. The road it was on is still called Hoyle Street by the way.

 

What was that real ale pub on the top of Spital Hill in the 90s called? - it had Bar Billiards, and the guy who had it always had classical music playing....

 

I think it was called something like the Golden Perch. I remember the Marston's beers and the landlord's rather delightful wife.

[In Uppers 10]

Gossips at Arundel Gate, on the corner, near Berlins.

 

OMG Every Friday night!!!! Sometimes landed in the gutter outside aswell

[In Uppers 10]

From my youth its Marlpes,The stonhouse,the fountain bar and legends (all town) and the white bear in ecco

In recent (ish) times The Sicey at shiregreen and lady's bridge in town and very recently The Highgreave in ecco

 

Has the High Greave closed?