firemanbob
Members-
Content Count
1,118 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Community Reputation
10 NeutralAbout firemanbob
-
Rank
Registered User
-
I didn't think it did.
-
Is it OK to pay disabled workers less than the minimum wage?
firemanbob replied to taxman's topic in General Discussions
.......................... -
British Bill of Rights - what do you want in it
firemanbob replied to tzijlstra's topic in General Discussions
Its odd that because a Google search does say that a website can be created for specific country access only and that others countries can be blocked. -
British Bill of Rights - what do you want in it
firemanbob replied to tzijlstra's topic in General Discussions
I agree, are you saying that website owners have no means to block users? -
British Bill of Rights - what do you want in it
firemanbob replied to tzijlstra's topic in General Discussions
The service he provided was in Amsterdam and the only way of accessing that service was for you to go to Amsterdam, so it isn't comparable to someone providing an internet based service that is accessible in the other countries. If he opened a shop in the UK then he should be obliged to follow UK laws. I don't know much about website construction and accessibility but from what I can gather it isn't impossible to construct a website that is only accessible from within the country of operation. So it would appear that he could have easily prevented American users from accessing his site. Choose which countries you want to ban and any visitors from that country get a HTTP/403 error with the standard message "Forbidden - Users from your country are not permitted to browse this site." -
British Bill of Rights - what do you want in it
firemanbob replied to tzijlstra's topic in General Discussions
If someone went to the US to rob a bank would you expect them to be prosecuted by the US? If the same person robbed the same bank but used a computer in the UK, why wouldn't it be appropriate to prosecute them in the US? -
British Bill of Rights - what do you want in it
firemanbob replied to tzijlstra's topic in General Discussions
Because he ignored their request to close the site down, ignored their threat of prosecution, created a new site when they closed the old one down, by the sounds of it he was a cocky sod that thought he could get away with flouting the law for profit. -
British Bill of Rights - what do you want in it
firemanbob replied to tzijlstra's topic in General Discussions
That fact that the site existed for the purpose of allowing people from all over the world to access pirate film means he was offering a service, from what I can gather he was asked to close the site down, warned that he faced prosecution if he didn't, he ignore the warning so the US shut the site down, he created another one so the US decided to prosecute him.