So where in Sheffield serves the best pint of the black stuff??, I have still to find it :o(.............

Dog and partridge, without question.

Guinness always tastes best in places where lots of it is drunk. I have come to the conclusion that draught guinness has a short shelf life, and where they don't sell much of it, it either settles out a bit or goes off a little. In a pub where half the patrons are drinking guinness it will always be good, but in a place where most drink lager and hardly any is sold it can taste "earthy"

Yes I agree the Dog & Partridge

Yep.it has got to be the D&P.A genuine Irish pub and not a pastiche dreamed up my a marketing guru in a far off office.Try a doorstep sandwich while you're there.

D & P by a country mile.

Can't really see the smoking ban taking off there, can anyone else.....

Jim:thumbsup:

IMO Fagan's on Broad Lane serves an absolute beauty of a pint of Guinness.

ohh im so glad i found this thread, i havent had a decent pint of guinness in sheffield since O'neills at broomhill shut down, it was that place that got me addicted to it :hihi: the worst ive had was in the feathers on POW that was totally unsupable :gag:

Best Guiness I ever had was funnily enough in Dublin. However, after 36 hours solid on the stuff, we had to resort to putting a Jameson's and blackcurrant into the pints to revive the tastebuds!

(Big jessie's I know!!!!)

Jim:thumbsup:

ive never been to ireland but would love to taste their guinness just to see what im missing :D

ive never been to ireland but would love to taste their guinness just to see what im missing :D

Its not that different TBH. A more consistent pint but not really any different from a good pint over here.

And yes, D & P does the best guinness in Sheffield. :thumbsup:

IMO Fagan's on Broad Lane serves an absolute beauty of a pint of Guinness.

and the landlord looks like john cleese

got to be the d@p for me tho

IMO Fagan's on Broad Lane serves an absolute beauty of a pint of Guinness.

Yes their guinness is good too, but the best thing about Fagans is the welcome I get when I go in. They treat me like a minor celebrity and my mates as trusted hangers-on.

How lucky I am to live in a wonderful city as this..

Dog and partridge.
Mm guiness:)

Since it's only a three minute walk between the two pubs, it's easy enough to check out both.

I prefer Fagins' Guiness


except of quiz night!

Best in Sheffield is definitely in the dog. Have had some good ones mind :)

Dog and partridge definatley is top class guinness, the new irish centre the alexandra has fine guinness as most people drink it there , the alexandra also has the best free duke box in the city for irish music.

And the alexandra does a fantastic evening meal at a very resonable price.







Paul is my name playing irish music is my game.