View Full Version : Would you lie?
Consider this hypothetical situation with a poll attached:
If your wife/partner, child or best friend told you that, although completely innocent, the police were trying to frame him/her for a serious crime, do you think that you might lie initially to help protect them?
Phanerothyme 16-11-2003, 21:30 depends if i believed them or not.
Originally posted by Phanerothyme
depends if i believed them or not.
Should I count that as a possibly?
Depends on the seriousness of the crime and what you're supposed to be lieing about.
Phanerothyme 16-11-2003, 22:05 Originally posted by Lickszz
Should I count that as a possibly?
no need, already voted possibly.
Everyone is voting possibly, including me. I agree though, it would depend on whether or not you believed them.
Surely there must be someone who trusts the police more than their closest friends and family?
gavinstamen 16-11-2003, 22:37 ----------
Originally posted by Lickszz
Surely there must be someone who trusts the police more than their closest friends and family?
I'd trust Tony Blair sooner than I'd trust the old Bill.
PaulTansley 17-11-2003, 05:50 Depends of how serious it is,,, personally i work for the HO so i would be out on my ear with any wrong doing of any kind so i would have to consider that to.
I voted no. If the police were truly trying to frame someone and I lied to protect them then surely the police would just throw their net wider and drag me in too. I'd rather work from outside prison to clear my friend/relative's name.
PaulTansley 17-11-2003, 11:00 Originally posted by max
I voted no. If the police were truly trying to frame someone and I lied to protect them then surely the police would just throw their net wider and drag me in too. I'd rather work from outside prison to clear my friend/relative's name. Sorry, i had to have a relook at the thread as i think i missed the point, Framed.
On doing that then yes if i thought my partner was being framed then i would help the police to clear there name.
Originally posted by The Cycleracer
Sorry, i had to have a relook at the thread as i think i missed the point, Framed.
On doing that then yes if i thought my partner was being framed then i would help the police to clear there name.
Look again, it's the police who are doing the framing.
Agent Dan 17-11-2003, 11:16 i reckon the best course would be to be honest - if they are being framed for something then the truth is the only thing that would really stand up in court...
Moon Maiden 17-11-2003, 11:19 I wouldn't need to lie :D
Moon
Originally posted by Agent Dan
i reckon the best course would be to be honest - if they are being framed for something then the truth is the only thing that would really stand up in court...
Yeah, but the police would lie in court if they were trying to frame someone. I've witnessed this first hand.
|