View Full Version : Who has been the greatest Motown artist ever?


Mudbug
09-01-2009, 15:13
Who has been the greatest Motown artist ever?

Stevie Wonder, Marvin Gaye, The Supremes, Smokey Robinson or someone else?

Celebrating 50 years of Motown records This Day in Music have launched a poll to find out what you think.

You can vote on http://www.thisdayinmusic.com

Some Facts:
As a songwriter, Berry Gordy had his first hit in 1957 with Reet Petite, sung by Jackie Wilson. Gordy quit his car factory job in the same year and went on to launch the independent Tamla Record Company on 12 January 1959, using a family loan of $800.

The original name for the Tamla label was "Tammy," after the Debbie Reynolds song, but it was taken

Motown, a blend of the words "motor" and "town", is also a nickname for Detroit - the label's original base and the historic home of the US car industry. Its original "Hitsville USA" headquarters in the city - which opened in January 1960 - housed the label's recording studio and offices.

Marv Johnson's song Come To Me was the label's first release, issued as Tamla 101.

The Marvelettes' Please Mister Postman was Motown's first US number one. Released in August 1961, it took 14 weeks to reach the top of the chart. (Also covered by the Beatles and was taken back to the US top spot by The Carpenters in 1974).

"Little Stevie Wonder" signed to Motown in 1961 and has been with the label ever since. He came into his own in the 1970s recording classic albums such as Talking Book and Songs in the Key of Life. His 1984 song I Just Called To Say I Love You is Motown's biggest-selling single.

The Beatles recorded three Motown songs on their 2nd album, Please Mister Postman, You’ve Really Got A Hold On Me and Money, (That’s What I want).

Martha And The Vandellas version of Dancing In The Street was recorded live in two takes. The first take was missed after the studio engineer forgot to turn the tape on. The song was original offered to Marvin Gaye who also has a writing credit on the song.

Marvin Gaye sang background on records by Chuck Berry and Etta James, was a member of The Moonglows and worked as a session drummer (he played on The Marvelettes' 1961 hit, "Please Mr. Postman" and Little Stevie Wonder's live version of 1963 hit, "Fingertips Pt. 2").

The Funk Brothers were the musicians who provided the backing on most Motown records between 1959 and 1972. It’s claimed they have played on more number one hits than Elvis, The Beach Boys, The Rolling Stones and The Beatles combined.

“I Heard It Through The Grapevine” written by Motown writers Norman Whitfield and Barrett Strong with backing played by the Funk Brothers - was a number one for Marvin Gaye in the US and the UK in 1968 and became Motown's biggest-selling record.

EdnaKrabappe
09-01-2009, 15:19
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b00gp3j1/The_Culture_Show_2008_2009_Martin_Freeman_Goes_to_ Motown/
This was an excellent programme on it the other night. As to my favourite, mm I'll have to think and come back and edit - so many.

Ok I've watched the programme again - am a little bit more in love with Martin Freeman - loved the record shop and think i know why i can't answer this question with one answer.
Motown was probably my first taste of looking back retrospectively at music and it was all thanks to a guy who used to do our local disco... Grandad Dave. Grandad Dave ran the Miner's welfare disco and would play Duran Duran and Spandau and the like but would throw in the odd Motown and Stax track (If this was a Stax thread I'd be saying Otis Redding without a doubt) I used to go up to him and ask him what he was playing and I turned into a little protegee, he'd play me stuff, lend me records, I remember feeling really giddy he'd lent me his Booker T and the MGs and that if I didn't take it back, there would be no Green onions to dance to the following week!
Anyway I invested aged about 12 in a fairly decent Motown/stax collection but they were all singles and then complilation albums when i worked out they were cheaper.
Hence why i can't say...
I do remember being obsessed with Jimmy Mack for ages though and learning 'the dance'. Heaven must have sent you by The Elgins, This old heart of mine Isley Brothers, and the Onion song for some reason by Marvin Gaye. Baby Love The supremes and Tears of a clown Smokey Robinson. Although my tastes in Motown have matured slightly since then, I heard some of these on Saturday night and felt very affectionately nostalgic towards them.

mark1971
09-01-2009, 15:39
What no Commodores?

Mr Westwood
09-01-2009, 17:57
As much as I love Motown I must say that after a good think I'm going to say that the music in the background was always what got me. I'd have to vote for the musicians who played the instruments. I know there was a documentary about them on a while back but it's late, I'm tired and I've hurt my typing finger.

Joe Momma
09-01-2009, 21:42
James Jamerson - The Don. :thumbsup:

http://www.bassland.net/jamersonhits.htm

shaznay
09-01-2009, 23:25
got to be stevie, marvin, diana in that order...:)

not wanted
10-01-2009, 01:33
I've got a much neglected blog that may interest you if you like 50's and 60's soul
http://www.whereimnotwanted.com/

BladeSteve
10-01-2009, 01:58
I would have to say Stevie Wonder for his talent and many memorable songs such as
'I Was Made To Love Her'
'Superstition'
'He's Misstra Know It All'
'Yester-Me, Yester-You, Yesterday'
'For Once In My Life'
'Sir Duke'
and my favourites 'Never Had A Dream Come True' and 'Angie Girl'.... just listening now .... wonderful.

Lestat
12-01-2009, 07:35
Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5 Michael Jackson and the Jackson 5

liza D
13-01-2009, 08:16
Marvin Gaye, without a doubt.

Really like most of the older artists from Motown having my teen yrs in the 70s. Think it's the music from those times that we remember most.

We either went for the Beatles and such or Motown, my family opted for Motown.

NEKRO138
13-01-2009, 08:33
Marvin Gaye or Stevie Wonder for me.

BasilRathbon
13-01-2009, 09:52
Neil Young.

NEKRO138
13-01-2009, 10:12
Neil Young.

Oh Basil, Neil Young wasn't on Motown. He's on Sheffield's very own Niche Records!

BasilRathbon
13-01-2009, 10:44
Oh Basil, Neil Young wasn't on Motown. He's on Sheffield's very own Niche Records!

That's where you're wrong, me laddie!

"Some Motown Trivia
Would you believe these were at one time contracted to Motown ?
Sammy Davis Jr
Kiki Dee
Neil Young
The Pretty Things

and that Tom Jones turned them down !!"

(from http://www.warringtonsoulclub.co.uk/page_583436.html)

Stick that in yer pipe and smoke it!

NEKRO138
13-01-2009, 10:49
That's where you're wrong, me laddie!

"Some Motown Trivia
Would you believe these were at one time contracted to Motown ?
Sammy Davis Jr
Kiki Dee
Neil Young
The Pretty Things

and that Tom Jones turned them down !!"

(from http://www.warringtonsoulclub.co.uk/page_583436.html)

Stick that in yer pipe and smoke it!

They've all also been on Niche Records I believe. Kiki Dee's was a banger.

not wanted
13-01-2009, 14:29
As much as I love Motown I must say that after a good think I'm going to say that the music in the background what always what got me. I'd have to vote for the musicians who played the instruments. I know there was a documentary about them on a while back but it's late, I'm tired and I've hurt my typing finger.

The film is called Standing in The Shadows Of Motown

splodgeyAl
13-01-2009, 14:57
As much as I love Motown I must say that after a good think I'm going to say that the music in the background what always what got me. I'd have to vote for the musicians who played the instruments. I know there was a documentary about them on a while back but it's late, I'm tired and I've hurt my typing finger.

Would agree with that Funk Bros all the way! But I would add a bit of Stevie Wonder, just cos the guy's close to a genius :thumbsup:

splodgeyAl
13-01-2009, 14:58
Oh Basil, Neil Young wasn't on Motown. He's on Sheffield's very own Niche Records!

NY's a label slut! He'll go with anyone for a wad of cash!!

Whatif wewin
13-01-2009, 19:09
If it's an artiste, then Stevie Wonder otherwise The four Tops for Reach out (I'll be there) alone.

Whatif wewin
13-01-2009, 20:22
The Four Tops reach out (I'll be there)
simply the best pop record ever made.
http://www.metacafe.com/watch/yt-PC4DKNfR0b4/the_four_tops_reach_out_ill_be_there_mpg/

cressida
14-01-2009, 00:01
Frankie Valli

Whatif wewin
14-01-2009, 13:39
Frankie Valli

I never knew Franki Valli was Motown.

I have just checked it on web, it seems that he was with them recording
'The Night ' in 1971 , but Motown had several issues with Franki and did not release the record till 1975. He had a great sound, but it was not really Motown based.
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=_hVDQmt4XWY

Whatif wewin
15-01-2009, 16:04
Frankie Valli

I have been listening to 'The Night' and singing along with it: big mistake I don't know how Frankie sings like that, I have a sore throat now.

jjbarnesfan
15-01-2009, 20:54
My vote would be for David Ruffin.

Sad ending for a man with such a distinctive voice.

Of course there must be a mention of J J Barnes.

MR BENN
16-01-2009, 01:25
Smokey Robinson for me -a legend