View Full Version : Top 10 worst football imports


Lickszz
26-02-2005, 12:22
Received this via email. Top 10 worst football imports. I notice Souness's name appears more than once...:D

1) Ali Dia (Southampton) November 1996.
We are in the office of Southampton manager Graeme Souness. The
telephone rings. It's - who else? - former World Footballer of the Year
George Weah, who, apropos of absolutely nothing, is offering the Saints his
30-year-old cousin Ali Dia, who he claims has played 13 times for Senegal.
Immediately, Souness agrees to take Dia on loan for a month and puts his
budding superstar on the bench for Saturday's home game with Leeds despite
never having seen him in competitive action. Dia was scheduled to take part
in a reserve game earlier in the week, but the weather intervened. After 32
minutes, Dia replaces Matthew Le Tissier. The sense is very much of a torch
being passed from one genius to another. Fifty-three jaw-dropping minutes
later, Dia himself is replaced, for the simple reason that he isn't a
footballer. Nor, it turns out, is he George Weah's cousin. Dia's agent,
however, does a Weah impersonation that is especially believable, if, like
Souness, you haven't actually met George Weah. Dia has not been heard of
since.

2) Winston Bogarde (Chelsea)
When Chelsea thrashed Barcelona 3-1 in the Champions League in 2000,
assistant manager Graham Rix admitted they had targeted the defender they
perceived as the Catalans' weak link, Winston Bogarde. Curious, then, that a
few weeks later, having fallen out with the Nou Camp management, the
Rotterdam-born Dutchman who represented Holland in the 1996 European
Championship and 1998 World Cup in France became Gianluca Vialli's final
signing, a free transfer replacement for Emerson Thome, albeit one on weekly
wages of £42,000. Four years later, the loyal servant left London
proclaiming himself "the biggest outcast in England" after starting just two
league games, both defeats. Heartwarmingly, at the beginning of last season,
one for which he was not even allocated a squad number, he declared: "I will
fight for my place like everybody else." This season, after training with
Ajax while allegedly looking for a club, he sensibly spent the transfer
window on holiday in Surinam. "But I believe an offer will come. I hope it
comes quickly." Don't we all?

3) Massimo Taibi (Manchester United)
How, then, to replace Peter Schmeichel? In 1999, with Raimond van
der Gouw always wearing his bridesmaid's outfit and Mark Bosnich too cocky
by half, Sir Alex Ferguson splashed out £4.5m on Venezia journeyman Massimo
Taibi. The omnipresent tracksuit bottoms should have caused Ferguson to
pause for thought. Instead, Taibi conceded two sloppy goals at Liverpool on
his debut and one to Wimbledon the following week. Then the fun began:
Southampton scored three at Old Trafford, including a Matthew Le Tissier
"shot" that trickled through Taibi's legs and was so soft, it barely crossed
the line. Eight days later, Chelsea put five past him at Stamford Bridge and
this Italian's job was over, little more than a month after it had began.
Taibi rotted in the reserves until Reggina took him on loan before a £2.5m
purchase at season's end. He was, noted a generous Roy Keane, "clearly a
good keeper". Clearly.

4) Marco Boogers (West Ham United)
In 1995, West Ham manager Harry Redknapp had the option of spending
£1m on Bristol Rovers sharpshooter Marcus Stewart or Dutch striker Marco
Boogers. Bravely, he plumped for Boogers, whom he hadn't actually seen play.
In the event, Boogers failed to start a game, but did achieve national
acclaim on his second substitute appearance when he was sent off for a
shocking tackle on Gary Neville, just 90 seconds after replacing Danny
Williamson. After two further substitute appearances against Aston Villa and
Blackburn, making a total of 83 competitive minutes in the Claret and Blue,
Boogers fled Upton Park to live in a caravan, accompanied by a doctor's note
saying he was mentally unfit to play football. After two years of Calor gas
canisters and chemical toilets, he returned to Dutch football with RKC
Waalwijk.

5) Elena Marcelino (Newcastle)
Having watched Marcelino play the proverbial blinder in the 1999 Cup
Winners' Cup final, Newcastle manager Ruud Gullit decided the
headband-wearing Spanish international defender was the man to shore up a
porous defence. He wasn't. Nor was he worth the £5.8m Gullit paid for him.
In his first game, the poor lamb hurt his groin and was substituted at
half-time. From there it was injuries all the way, including a lengthy
absence caused by a poorly finger. Four years and 19 calamitous starts
later, he was shipped back to Spain. In a crate, for all the Gallowgate End
supporters cared. "The fans called me a thieving Spaniard and a gypsy who
was robbing the club's cash," he said. For probably the first time in their
relationship, chairman Freddie Shepherd almost concurred: "They say you
should only say good things about people, so I'll say this: he's gone -
good."

6) Corrado Grabbi (Blackburn Rovers)
How the Italians chuckled in 2001 when Graeme Souness, manager of
Blackburn Rovers, paid £6.75m for Juventus cast-off Corrado Grabbi, who had
just scored 19 goals in 34 Serie B (not to be confused with Serie A) games
for Ternana. Grabbi's work ethic was never in doubt, but two goals in 30
Premiership games suggested Souness might have been better buying a Serie A
player. After an especially profligate performance in the 2003 Uefa Cup
against Genclerbirgli, Souness lost patience. Grabbi was bought by Ancona.
The fee was undisclosed, but it wasn't £6.75m.

7) Sean Dundee (Liverpool)
In 1998, Karlsruhe were relegated from the Bundesliga. Their tubby
star forward, Sean "Crocodile" Dundee, scored just three times. These facts
did not deter Liverpool manager Roy Evans from splashing out £2m for the
German international who claimed to be as fast as Michael Owen. In fact, he
wasn't as fast as Liverpool fan Michael Howard. Liverpool's official website
raised the notion that Dundee was "possibly the worst player to have donned
the red of Liverpool".

8 ) Pal Lydersen (Arsenal)
Poor Pal. It wasn't really his fault that he wasn't up to the task.
The tall Norwegian full-back had been signed in 1991 by manager George
Graham, in effect, for a bung from Lydersen's disgraced agent, Rune Hauge.
Lydersen's positional sense gave Tony Adams the screaming heebie-jeebies,
and his overall standard was more Bury than Highbury. Graham was in a tricky
position, so he hit on the inventive wheeze of only playing him in
meaningless games, before releasing him four years later after 15 starts.

9) Wim Jonk (Sheffield Wednesday)
Not only did Jonk look like Michael Palin, but he was as tough in
the tackle as him. The Dutchman, signed for £2.5m from PSV Eindhoven in
1998, lolloped anonymously around Wednesday's midfield for two seasons, the
second of which saw them relegated. After experiencing the hurly burly of
two First Division games, he sat out the remaining year of his contract,
citing a tummy ache. At the end of that season, he retired to concentrate on
his poetry. Wednesday fans had their own rhymes for him.

10) Li Weifeng (Everton)
By remarkable coincidence, the moment Everton signed a sponsorship
deal with a Chinese company in 2002, two Chinese players arrived at
Goodison. Li Tie acquitted himself moderately well. The more introspective,
chronically homesick Li Weifeng, who spoke no English, did not, despite his
initial assertion that "I am very happy to be here because I like Liverpool
very much. The Beatles are very famous in China". He got himself booked in
his sole Premiership outing, a defeat at Southampton. Soon he was on a plane
home, and would not return to Merseyside for all the tea in China.

Ginner
26-02-2005, 14:17
I vote for Patrick Blondeau (SWFC)

A French International defender who, even when picked at right back, played right wing, leaving gaping holes in an already shaky SWFC defence.

I think he was even quoted in The Star as saying that David Pleat had asked him to oversee the defensive training, such a genius was he (and Pleat for that matter).

Signed in the summer, he'd gone by the end of that season.

Good old Pleaty - admired and revered by all Wednesdayites.

Snook
26-02-2005, 18:46
Not an import, but a really bad signing.

Carlton Palmer - Stockport

The most overdue sacking in the history of football took place this September, as Stockport County finally booted out the pathetic Carlton Palmer – the manager that makes Glen Hoddle look like Bill Shankly.

Palmer was made player-boss in November 2001 after Stockport had started the season like an iceberg-hit ship. If Stockport were flirting with relegation at the time, then Palmer’s appointment instantly pulled it, married it and had kids with the thing.

After just two games in charge, Stockport went on a record equalling nine consecutive defeats, after which Palmer started his series of disillusioned ramblings by saying, "Who is to say I will not be manager of England in 10 years' time?" Only Carlton knows how much post he got after that comment, but there was little surprise that the defeat’s record was broken in their next game.

Stockport’s rapid relegation was also a record and they equalled the biggest number of defeats for a Division One team in the process. They then started the 2002/03 season hovering around the Division Two relegation zone. Unsurprisingly, the County fans were not too happy with the catastrophic plight of their beloved club, to which Palmer shockingly responded with, “I’ve been in the game a long time and know football supporters are fickle.”

A very late flurry of wins ensured that Stockport just about managed to keep their place in the prestigious world of Second Division football. But come 2003/04 and enough was enough - Palmer was given his well-deserved P45. With an abysmal record of just 25 wins from 92 games and County back in the relegation zone, the surprise was that he had lasted 18 games let alone 18 months.

Of course, despite losing over 50% of his games – most of which were played in a Division lower than the one he started in – Palmer, had his own, unique way of looking at things, “I'm obviously disappointed. It's more to do with politics than football, but I don't want to elaborate.”

Of course it was Carlton, of course.

deanprez
27-02-2005, 03:14
Thomas Brolin at LEEDS !

The man's sock's were a 38 waiste !!

And he had an accident involving an ELK of all thing's !!

Lickszz
27-02-2005, 03:41
Brolin did come with a first class pedigree and they had seem what he could do when he destroyed England whil playing for Sweden. However, for some reason when he arrived at Leeds he went on the pies and lager and it all went to pot. It's estimated that he cost them around £7.5m. :hihi:

Kristian
27-02-2005, 03:55
Best football export: David and Victoria Beckham! :clap:

K x

igm1
27-02-2005, 09:01
Originally posted by Kristian
Best football export: David and Victoria Beckham! :clap:

K x

I have to second that!

Agent Gypo
27-02-2005, 11:23
One of the worst SUFC imports I can remember was Gus Uhlenbeek.

He couldn't pass, mark, tackle or distribute the ball at all.

briggy1967
07-06-2005, 21:47
Deffo agree with wim jonk for us (owls) cost us a fortune but to that list u can add benito carbone,Orlando Trustful (great name but bloody awful player) and Andy Hinchcliffe.

Arnold
08-06-2005, 15:34
For Chelsea: Winston Bogarde was an awful signing, so was Chris sutton. Brian Laudrup and Peirluigi Casigraghi both promised to be good but Laudrup got "homesick" and casiraghi got injured.

Diego Forlan for Man Utd was pretty pointless, as was Masimo Tiagi for them, and Eric Djemba for them-he was said to be the next Roy Keane! I think Jens Lehman has been a bad import for Arsenal. I think Nickolas Anelka could have been a good import for them, but he turned out to be a bad imprt. I think if you are a Juventus fan, you will be saying the Ian Rush was a bad import for you! Ian came back to England swiftly from Italy after having a troubled time and his reason for leaving italy to return was "It was like living in a foreign country"!!!

Geordiecarl
08-06-2005, 15:48
Gerrard Prounier (Manchester United)

I think he only played 2 games for them, he was bald and french! Can anyone else enlighten me as it was a good 10 years ago and he is just a small memory

Guderian
11-06-2005, 16:48
It was William Prunier. He played twice. At home v QPR (looked ok) then away at Spurs, where he was an utter disgrace. Was then packed off back to France quick smart!!

P.S In reply to an earlier post, Forlan didnt cut it at Utd, but just to make everyone aware he has just won (shared with Henry), the European Golden Boot for most number of goals for Villareal!
He only played 3/4 of the season in La Liga, but managed to overhaul Eto of Barcelona.
And two 2 goals at anfield for United. Thanks Diego.

plekhanov
14-06-2005, 12:30
Originally posted by Guderian
It was William Prunier. He played twice. At home v QPR (looked ok) then away at Spurs, where he was an utter disgrace. Was then packed off back to France quick smart!!

P.S In reply to an earlier post, Forlan didnt cut it at Utd, but just to make everyone aware he has just won (shared with Henry), the European Golden Boot for most number of goals for Villareal!
He only played 3/4 of the season in La Liga, but managed to overhaul Eto of Barcelona.
And two 2 goals at anfield for United. Thanks Diego.
Old Trafford does seem to bring out the worst in some players, Forlan never quite seemed to fit in or be given much of a chance by Ferguson he does seem to have been an excellent export though.

Veron & Kleberson cost more and despite playing superbly elsewhere never made it at Manu, I’d say they were worse imports than Forlan who cost less and contributed more.

amamshebab
02-07-2005, 15:54
jonk was a waste of space but carbone? little italian wizard. Also agree on blondeau, surely he should have been playing on the other side of the city?

desy
03-07-2005, 08:58
Michael De Piadi

Wim Vonk

James Quinn(irish)

ReginaldD
14-07-2005, 15:24
Massimo Maccarone- Middlesbrough
terrible signing 8m waste of money