beckham , giggs, ronaldo so whos the best ?

all wingers but at there height of there time becks and giggs was they better than ronaldo ?

i think its a hard one to call

I wouldn't mind all three in my team but if I could only choose one it would have to be Ronaldo - his wing play is as good as Giggs and he isn't totally reliant on speed - he can beat a man far better than Beckham ever could, his dead ball play is equal although crossing isn't as good - but a far better goalscorer than both - and better in the air.

As a winger goes, Giggs.

As a United season ticket holder for many years, I have to say this one is pretty easy.

Ronaldo, followed by Giggs, then followed (a long way behind) is Beckham.

All three are fantastic players, but Ronaldo is the best, even at this early stage of his career.

There was some doubt about it earlier in the season, with some saying Kaka was better, but for me, he is the best in the world. His goalscoring record is absolutely incredible.

He's going to go on and beat George Best's record this season and that puts him on the highest plane.

Ronaldo for me and we haven't seen him at his peak yet, the scary thing is he's still improving. I think he'll go on the be the best player Manchester United have ever had, if he sticks with it and doesn't up sticks to Madrid.

His skill is undoubted, but surely in terms of club achievements, Ronaldo isn't anywhere near Giggs and Beckham yet.

He's a brilliant player, but he might not be at Man Utd when he's 24, never mind 34.

And let's not forget they all have different roles as players, so we're not comparing like for like.

As a United season ticket holder for many years, I have to say this one is pretty easy.

Ronaldo, followed by Giggs, then followed (a long way behind) is Beckham.

Have to agree with guderian. Though I dont think beckham is that far behind giggs. The main difference to the other two is that Beckham could never go past a man. While the other two can(in Giggs case, infrequently!) tear defences apart.

Silly Question

1:Ronaldo
2:Giggs
3:Beckham

1) Giggs
2) Ronaldo
3) Beckham

Ronaldo by a country mile although I do wish Ryan Giggs hadn't chose to play for Wales.

Ronaldo by a country mile although I do wish Ryan Giggs hadn't chose to play for Wales.

yes so do I, but I also think Giggs moves around the pitch more, helping out in midfield and at times defence - I think Ronaldo stays up front more, Beckham, and I've seen him play is very inspirational but wouldn't be as effective without his skill with free kicks

Ronaldo by a country mile although I do wish Ryan Giggs hadn't chose to play for Wales.

There is nothing wrong in being proud of your country.

There is nothing wrong in being proud of your country.
Didn't say there was.

there all have great skill BUT i still think its a hard one to call!! becks and giggs have had injurys in there time! if ronaldo gets a bad injury have to see how he reacts to it ! i.e M OWEN has never been the same player since his injurys