Andy C
03-02-2005, 12:32
From Sheffieldtoday.net (Sheffield Star website)
THE chances of fluoride being added to tap water in Sheffield and the rest of South Yorkshire seemed remote today after the city council reaffirmed its objections.
Councillors voted 57 to 14 against the addition of fluoride to Yorkshire Water supplies in a free vote at a full meeting of Sheffield Council.
Health authorities are unlikely to proceed with a fluoride project without the backing of the council.
Some Labour councillors spoke in favour of its addition, arguing the benefit in dental health outweighed any risks.
Labour's Tony Damms said fluoride had been added to tap water in some parts of the USA for almost 60 years without any legal claims against it.
Colleague Peter Price and cabinet member for education Coun Angela Smith also spoke in favour.
But another Labour councillor, Jean Cromar, said: "Tooth decay is not a fluoride deficiency disease but the result of poor dental hygiene and a generally faulty diet, mainly an over consumption of sugar."
THE chances of fluoride being added to tap water in Sheffield and the rest of South Yorkshire seemed remote today after the city council reaffirmed its objections.
Councillors voted 57 to 14 against the addition of fluoride to Yorkshire Water supplies in a free vote at a full meeting of Sheffield Council.
Health authorities are unlikely to proceed with a fluoride project without the backing of the council.
Some Labour councillors spoke in favour of its addition, arguing the benefit in dental health outweighed any risks.
Labour's Tony Damms said fluoride had been added to tap water in some parts of the USA for almost 60 years without any legal claims against it.
Colleague Peter Price and cabinet member for education Coun Angela Smith also spoke in favour.
But another Labour councillor, Jean Cromar, said: "Tooth decay is not a fluoride deficiency disease but the result of poor dental hygiene and a generally faulty diet, mainly an over consumption of sugar."