View Full Version : Offside contreversey explained by a Spanish doctor


duffman
18-12-2004, 20:29
The contreversial decisions that are in nearly every game more often than not are offside decisions.

Now a Spanish doctor has given an explanation as to why many of them are deemed to be the wrong decision.

So does this new theory bring in the question weather or not tv technology should be brough in to football for goal decsions and maybe even on the offside ruling.

Lickszz
19-12-2004, 12:13
I think Human error has a role within sport to a certain extent. Otherwise what would everyone talk about?

As long as the officials are not corrupt.

mat1978
19-12-2004, 13:47
I think for things such as offsides then we should just leave it to the Officials. The amount of tricky offside decisions would mean constant interuption to the game. But I would say that in a case where the ref isnt quite sure if the ball has crossed the goal line then I think theres a case for TV replays before a decision is made. Only in this instance though.

As Lickszz says, the human error aspect of sport is crucial to the excitment. Over the course of a season things even up anyway.

Mat:cool:

igm1
19-12-2004, 17:01
Originally posted by Lickszz
I think Human error has a role within sport to a certain extent. Otherwise what would everyone talk about?


I'm torn on this issue

Lickszz makes a good point, human error does have a role within sport.

However, the number of times decisions have gone wrong.

How would they go about installing TV technology in football.

Ned Ludd
20-12-2004, 10:55
It's time to do away with the latest interpretatation of this Law for a start.
I can't imagine why EUEFA and FIFA have had to interefe.
The example shown on yesterdays MOTD 2 just shows what a comlpete ******ks it is.